Events

Palmerville: skip one control on each side of the map

Runners Shop Series

Three orienteers wading single file through waist-high grass along a narrow path, the one in front reading his map
Through the long grass at Palmerville. Photo: John Harding

This morning’s ACT Short Series race, Runners Shop Series #3, was at Palmerville in Canberra’s north, on a new 1:4,000 map by Grant McDonald. Jarrad Needham set the courses, and he gave them a twist: on each side of the map, you could leave out any one control you liked.

That turns every control into a small decision. Is this one worth the trip, or is the next leg short enough without it? The Moderate courses had a phi loop and two forks as well, and meshO Manager checked every card against all of it at the download.

The day in numbers

  • 123 starters: 105 on the Moderate courses and 18 on the Beginner course
  • 3.2 km and 23 controls on Short A and Short B, with the map turned over after control 12
  • 1 radio control, at 12 where the map turns, so splits came in from halfway round
  • 16:22, Hayden Dent’s winning time on the Moderate courses
Short A, both sides of the map. The note in red on each side is the rule: one control may be missed on this side.

The phi loop and the forks

The two Moderate courses, Short A and Short B, were one class. Manager didn’t need to be told who ran which: it picked each runner’s course from the punches on their card.

Controls 2 to 8 are a phi loop. 101 and 103 are each visited twice, with a short leg straight between them; one loop goes west through 104 and 105, and the other east through 106. Short A and Short B run the same six legs, but in a different order, so the runner in front of you might not be going where you’re going.

Short Afrom 1to 91234562, 61013, 8103410451057106Short Bfrom 1to 91234562, 71014, 8103510461053106The order the legs are run in.Beside each circle: its number on the course, and its code.

The phi loop, controls 2 to 8. The same six legs, run in a different order on each course. Drawn from the control positions in meshO Manager.

After the map turns, the courses split twice. At 15, Short A goes to 114 and Short B to 116. At 18, Short A goes to 119 and Short B to 108. Then they join again at 120 and finish together.

Part 1one control may be skippedPhi loop, controls 2 to 811029107101091111112110Turn the mapoverPart 2one control may be skipped1311214115151141161611717118181191081912020124211212211323122Short AShort BBoth

The whole course. One skip is allowed on each side of the map, and the two forks are on Part 2.

Setting it up in Manager

The courses were imported as usual. Then, in Edit course, on the Controls tab:

  1. Click between 12 and 13 in the strip of controls. That splits the course in two where the map turns over.
  2. Set Skip any to 1 control for Start to 12, and 1 control for 13 to the finish.
  3. Save, and do the same for Short B.
The Controls tab of Edit course for Short A at Palmerville: the course's 23 controls in a numbered strip, split by a line between 12 and 13, then a Start to 12 row and a 13 to the finish row, each allowing 1 control to be skipped, with Never two in a row unticked.
Short A, split between 12 and 13, with one skip allowed on each side.

That’s all of it. The sections go by position on the course, not by control code, which matters here: 101 and 103 are each visited twice on Part 1, and missing one visit only uses up that one visit’s skip. The Courses list shows the rule beside each course, so it’s easy to check before the start.

The Courses list for the event: Beginner with Skips, skip one; Short A and Short B, each with Skips, skip one of 1–12, skip one of 13–23, and their 23 controls, with the radio control 110 marked.
Each course’s skip rule beside its controls.

At the download, a card with one control missing on each side is OK, and its result lists the controls the runner skipped. Hayden Dent won without 111 on Part 1 and 121 on Part 2.

Hayden Dent's result in meshO Manager: status OK, class Moderate, course Auto (Short B), race time 16:22, Skipped 111 and 121, position 1 of 127.
The winner’s result. Manager chose Short B from his punches, and lists the two controls he skipped.
After the run: which one did you skip? Photos: John Harding

Which control was worth skipping?

Every runner’s splits are in Manager, so we can work out what each skip was worth. For each runner who skipped a control, compare the time the field took over the two legs around it with the time that runner took on the direct leg instead. Each runner’s times are scaled to their own pace over the rest of the course, so a fast runner’s skip and a slower runner’s skip can be compared.

How much time each skip saved

One dot per runner who skipped that control, Short A and Short B together. The bar is the middle runner. Controls that fewer than three runners skipped are left out.

−1:00−0:3000:301:001:302:00Part 1, controls 1 to 12107A9 / B99 runners1:31104A4 / B512 runners1:21106A7 / B327 runners0:55105A5 / B63 runners0:42102A1 / B13 runners0:21101A2, A6 / B2, B74 runners0:18Part 2, controls 13 to 23117A16 / B1624 runners1:07120A19 / B195 runners0:41121A21 / B2110 runners0:40114A155 runners0:27113A22 / B229 runners0:16119A183 runners0:14115A14 / B143 runners0:05Time saved by skipping it (minutes:seconds). Left of 0, the skip cost time.
Time saved is what the field took over the two legs around the control, less what the runner took on the direct leg instead, both scaled to the runner's own pace over the rest of the course. Data: meshO Manager splits, Moderate class.

On Part 1, the best skip was 107, control 9: a median of 1:31 saved. That’s more than the distance alone explains, because the time the field lost around 107 went into finding it as much as getting there. 104 was close behind at 1:21. The most popular skip, 106, chosen by 27 runners, saved only 55 seconds: it sits right between 101 and 103, so leaving it out is the obvious short cut on the map, but it wasn’t the biggest one.

On Part 2, 117 was the clear winner, at 1:07. It was also the popular choice: 24 runners skipped it, and all but one of them gained between 44 and 78 seconds. Nothing else on Part 2 saved more than about 40 seconds.

So the best pair was 107 and 117, worth about two and a half minutes to a mid-pack runner. Three runners skipped exactly those two, the fastest of them Oscar Needham, ninth in 23:20. Twenty-one of the 91 finishers on the Moderate courses didn’t skip anything at all.

The dots to the left of zero are a reminder that a skip only saves time if you hit the next control. Someone who skipped 106 and then lost two and a half minutes on the direct leg would have been better off punching it.

When it goes wrong

Skip two controls on the same side and the card is MP, even if the other side has its skip unused. Mica Walter ran 19:40, fast enough for sixth, but on Part 2 punched 116, Short B’s control, where Short A had 114, and also left out 117. That’s two controls missing from Short A’s Part 2.

Mica Walter's result in meshO Manager: status MP, with Controls 107, 114 and 117 are missing. The strip of controls shows 107 at 9, 114 at 15 and 117 at 16 in red, and an extra punch at 116 in a dashed outline.
Over the allowance on Part 2. Manager shows the card’s missing controls in red, and the extra punch at 116, Short B’s fork, in a dashed outline.

At the download, Manager showed MP straight away, with the controls that caused it.

Thank you

Thank you to Jarrad for courses that had everyone talking at the picnic tables afterwards, to Grant McDonald for the map, to John Harding for the photos, to Orienteering ACT and The Runners Shop, and to every volunteer who put out and brought in the controls.

Full results and splits are on meshO Events: Runners Shop Series #3, Palmerville. To set up skips for your own event, see Courses with skips in the meshO Manager docs.

Bringing in the controls. Photo: John Harding

The meshO Manager newsletter

Every second week: new guides, posts and video tips for the people who run events with meshO Manager. Unsubscribe from any issue.

Subscribe by email

Opens an email to sales@mesho.live. Send it, and we add the address it comes from.

Related

Running an event? Tell us about it.

Hardware, software or the whole day — we’ll quote for what you need.